A few days back, a friend called me to discuss a new stock idea that he was excited about.
“Do you know that Rakesh Jhunjunwala’s investment in Delta Corp was close to 400 crores a few months back. And now even when the stock has gone down by more than 60 percent, he is still holding on to it. With so much at stake, I am sure Delta corp is his high conviction stock.”
“We can’t say for sure if Delta corp is his high conviction stock,” I said. “He has many other stocks in his portfolio.”
“Yes, but look at the size of his investment. Four hundred crores is not a small amount.” My friend reasoned.
I could not find a convincing answer to counter my friend’s argument at that time but I kept thinking about it. This post is my attempt to answer my friend and offer some insights on how to think more rigorously before deciding to copy other successful investors.
[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
Historian Niall Ferguson observed —
The dead outnumber the living fourteen to one, and we ignore the accumulated experience of such a huge majority of mankind at our peril.
So let me take you back a few thousand years in history.
Mithridates was king of Pontus and Armenia Minor in northern Anatolia from about 120–63 BC. He is remembered as one of the Roman Republic’s most formidable and successful enemies. His father, Mithridate V, was assassinated by enemies by poisoning his food. To avoid having the same fate as his father, Mithridates cultivated an immunity to poisons by regularly ingesting sub-lethal doses of the same.
Nassim Nicholas Taleb, in his excellent book Antifragile, writes —
Mithridatization is the result of an exposure to a small dose of a substance that, over time, makes one immune to additional, larger quantities of it. It is the sort of approach used in vaccination and allergy medicine.
Chanakya also used this ancient practice of Mithridatization while he served as the Prime Minister of Chandragupta Maurya. Chanakya started adding small amounts of poison in Chandragupta’s food to slowly build immunity against common toxins enemies used during those times.
But unlike King Mithridates, Chanakya’s story gets more interesting.
One day the queen, Durdha, shared the food with Chandragupta. Since she was not used to eating poisoned food, she died. Unfortunately, she was pregnant at that time. Chanakya decided that the baby should not die; hence he cut open the belly of the queen and took out the baby. The baby grew up to become Chandragupta’s heir — King Bindusara. A drop (bindu in Sanskrit) of poison had passed to the baby’s head, and hence Chanakya named him Bindusara.
The legend goes that a few conspirators in Bindusara’s court convinced him that Chanakya was responsible for murdering Durdha. When Bindusara confronted Chanakya, it became too hard for Chanakya to bear the insult and he went on a fast until he died of starvation.
The lesson I draw from the stories of Mithridates and Chanakya is that the ability to stomach the risk is based on how well someone has prepared himself to deal with it.
When Rakesh Jhunjhunwala decides to put hundreds of crores in a single stock, he is not going to bat an eyelid if his investment tanks by 50-60% like it happened in the case of Delta Corp recently. Even if it goes to zero, it won’t affect his portfolio much because of two reasons.
First, his bet on Delta is a tiny part of his overall portfolio. Second, he’s prepared to take that loss. Put simply, over the past several decades, investors like him have mithridatized themselves against such risks.
Blindly following Mr. Jhunjhunwala exposes a new investor to the same risk Durdha faced.
Similarly, many novice investors make the same blunder when they try to emulate Warren Buffett.
An academic study in 2014 found that Warren Buffett’s company Berkshire Hathaway had been leveraging its capital by as much as 60% and that level of leverage was a significant factor in Berkshire’s outsized returns.
Based on this academic study, if a small investor concluded that one could use leverage to generate superior returns, it would be a grave mistake. If you dig deeper into Berkshire’s financials, you will discover that the leverage is in the form of Float which is very different from the debt that’s available for an individual investor. Float is an interest-free loan that is available only to profitable insurance companies and Buffett has several sprawling insurance operations running under the aegis of Berkshire Hathaway.
Putting Buffett’s leverage methods next to the ordinary margin investing is like comparing apples to oranges. And because of superficial understanding of how Buffett invests, critiques sometimes accuse him of violating his own advice.
Remember, Buffett never misses an opportunity to warn investors about the dangers of debt. On one instance he quipped —
My partner Charlie says there are only three ways a smart person can go broke: liquor, ladies and leverage. Now the truth is — the first two he just added because they started with L — it’s leverage.
Do as I say, not as I do — that’s how one should learn from Buffett. Not copying his methods mindlessly but listening to what he recommends. Unfortunately, unlike Warren Buffett, very few other successful investors are interested in teaching others. So people make the mistake of taking the actions of other successful investors as their silent advice.
In his 2002 letter to investors, the Buffett wrote —
We try to be alert to any sort of mega catastrophe risk, and that posture may make us unduly apprehensive about the burgeoning quantities of long-term derivatives contracts and the massive amount of uncollateralized receivables that are growing alongside. In our view, however, derivatives are financial weapons of mass destruction, carrying dangers that, while now latent, are potentially lethal.
Now one could argue that if you look at Buffett’s transactions, you’d find that he has made heavy use of derivatives over the past few decades. But most of these derivative trades are not exchange-traded ones that are usually available to small investors. At Buffett’s scale, he gets the advantage of specially designed deals that put odds in his favour.
In 2008 letter to investors, Buffett explained —
Considering the ruin I’ve pictured, you may wonder why Berkshire is a party to 251 derivatives contracts…The answer is simple: I believe each contract we own was mispriced at inception, sometimes dramatically so. …
Our derivatives dealings require our counterparties to make payments to us when contracts are initiated. Berkshire therefore, always holds the money, which leaves us assuming no meaningful counterparty risk. As of year end, the payments made to us less losses we have paid – our derivatives “float,” so to speak – totaled $8.1 billion. This Float is similar to insurance float: If we break even on an underlying transaction, we will have enjoyed the use of free money for a long time.
In the end, it all boils down to how deeply do you understand what you’re getting into because that’s where the real risk comes from — not knowing what you’re doing.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years