• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

The One Percent Almanack

Wit and Wisdom on Investing, Business, and Life

  • Home
  • Members
  • Log In|Log Out
  • Show Search
Hide Search

Bookworm: The Little Book That Beats The Market

June 30, 2017

Before you get put off by the cheesy title, let me share a few words about the author. Joel Greenblatt managed money for Gotham Capital from 1985 to 2006 and generated an annualized returns of 40 percent during that period. In case that didn’t make you jump on your seat, let me put that number in proper perspective (and give you a glimpse into the massive power of compounding). If you invested Rs 1 lac in Gotham fund, over 20 years your initial investment would have turned into a staggering sum of around Rs 8.4 crore

Joel is a practitioner of value investing and pretty successful at it. And to add icing on the cake, Greenblatt is an adjunct professor at Columbia Business School. Which means, he’s an experienced teacher too. This unique mix of skills is extremely rare in the world of investing. This ability to teach by simplifying the ideas is what separates the likes of Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger from all the other successful value investors. Joel Greenblatt is pretty much up there in the same league.

As the title says, it’s a little book. A little over 100 short pages. But don’t get fooled by its brevity and the simplicity of Greenblatt’s message.

<!–more–>[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

For a part time investor, the most viable option for preserving the capital and beating the inflation, in the long run, is to invest money through SIP (systematic investment plan) in a low-cost index fund. But that will only ensure that your investment returns are same as the broader market. What if you want to return better than indexes? The answer, most people think, is to give their money to professional money managers. Unfortunately, that’s where most people get taken for a ride. Greenblatt writes –

After more than 25 years of investing professionally and after 9 years of teaching at an Ivy League business school, I am convinced of two things:

If you really want to “beat the market,” most professionals and academics can’t help you, and

That leaves only one real alternative: You must do it yourself.

The book, as we’ll shortly see, is primarily about “A Magic Formula”. Although the formula is easy to use and will not take much of your time, it will work for you only if you make the effort to understand why it works, writes Greenblatt. The formula works because at its heart it’s based on the two basic tenets of value investing.

First, buying good companies at bargain prices makes sense. On average, this is what the magic formula does. Second, it can take Mr. Market several years to recognize a bargain. Therefore, the magic formula strategy requires patience.

So, on one hand, this little book simplifies investing for you but on another, the simplicity itself makes it difficult for most people to implement it. Andrew Tobias, who wrote a book called The Only Investment Guide You’ll Ever Need, writes about Joel’s book – The best thing about this book is that most people won’t believe it. Or, believing it, won’t have the patience to follow its advice.

Graham’s Magic Formula

The inspiration for magic formula came from Benjamin Graham, the man who’s considered the father of value investing and pioneer of concepts like Mr. Market and Margin of Safety.

Graham felt that most individual investors, and even many professional investors, would have a hard time making the type of predictions and performing the level of analysis necessary to value and invest in businesses on their own. Graham figured that by sharing a simple formula, one that sense and had worked well in the past, individual investors would be able to achieve excellent investment results with a high degree of safety…Graham’s formula involved purchasing companies whose stock prices were so low that the purchase price was actually lower than the proceeds that would be received from simply shutting down the business and selling off the company’s assets in a fire sale…Graham showed that a simple system for finding obviously cheap stocks could lead to safe and consistently good investment returns.

Unfortunately, Graham’s formula doesn’t work anymore. It was designed for an and era that had severe impressions of 1929 stock market crash and net-net stocks were commonly available. Today, net-nets are almost impossible to find.

The New Magic Formula

Greenblatt’s magic formula is based on two parameters. First is Earnings Yield –

You would rather have a higher earnings yield than a lower one; you would rather the business earn more relative to the price you are paying than less. [In other words] paying a bargain price when you purchase a share in a business is a good thing.

The second is Return on Capital – You would rather own a business that earns a high return on capital than one that earns a low return on capital. [In other words] Purchase a business that can invest its own money at high rates of return rather than purchasing a business that can only invest at lower ones.

Combining these two simple ideas, the magic formula is simply this

– If you stick to buying good companies (ones that have a high return on capital) and to buying those companies only at bargain prices (at prices that give you a high earnings yield), you can end up systematically buying many of the good companies that crazy Mr. Market has decided to literally give away.

So, here’s how the formula works –

The formula starts with a list of the largest 3,500 companies available for trading on one of the major U.S. stock exchanges. It then assigns a rank to those companies, from 1 to 3,500, based on their return on capital. The company whose business had the highest return on capital would be assigned a rank of 1, and the company with the lowest return on capital would receive a rank of 3,500.

Next, the formula follows the same procedure, but this time, the ranking is done using earnings yield. The company with the highest earnings yield is assigned a rank of 1, and the company with the lowest earnings yield receives a rank of 3,500. Likewise, the company with the 153rd highest earnings yield out of our list of 3,500 companies would be assigned a rank of 153.

Finally, the formula just combines the rankings. The formula isn’t looking for the company that ranks best on return on capital or the one with the highest earnings yield. Rather, the formula looks for the companies that have the best combination of those two factors. So, a company that ranked 232nd best in return on capital and 153rd highest in earnings yield would receive a combined ranking of 385 (232 + 153). A company that ranked 1st in return on capital but only 1,150th best in earnings yield would receive a combined ranking of 1,151 (1,150 + 1)

Greenblatt figured that if one chose top 30 stocks from that combined ranking list, the portfolio should produce, in Graham’s words, satisfactory returns. This magic formula was back-tested on 17 years of past data (1988 – 2004), and the results were jaw dropping. The magic formula beat the market (S&P 500 Index) by 18 percent points.

Before you get too excited and put all your money into magic formula, there’s one thing that you should keep in mind. With smaller companies, liquidity may be a problem i.e., small companies have very few shares available for purchase. Which means, even a small amount of demand for those shares can push share prices higher and you may not be able to buy/sell all the shares that you wanted to buy at the current prices. That’s why it’s important that the companies chosen by the magic formula be large. So, instead of ranking the top 3,500 companies, you may want to restrict yourself to top 1000 companies.

Interestingly, when magic formula was back-tested by starting with an initial list of biggest 1000 companies, the formula again trounced S&P 500 by more than 10 percentage points.

The magic formula has another advantage over Ben Graham’s formula. Greenblatt writes –

Remember how Ben Graham had his own “magic formula”? Buying a group of stocks that could meet the strict requirement of Graham’s formula was a great way to make money. Unfortunately, in today’s market, few, if any, companies qualify for purchase under Graham’s original formula. That means Graham’s formula isn’t as useful as it once was. Fortunately, our magic formula doesn’t seem to have that problem. It is merely a ranking formula. By definition, there always have to be stocks that rank at the top. Not only that, because the formula appears to work in order, we’re not limited to just the top 30 stocks. Since the entire group of top-ranked stocks does well, there should always be plenty of high-performing stocks to choose from!

If it’s so simple to produce market-beating returns merely by using a simple formula and if such a known and successful investor like Greenblatt has written openly about it, why is it that even after a decade after this book was published, hardly anyone in the investment world talks about this strategy?

The reason is that the magic formula usually lags the market returns in short term i.e. if one were to compare the magic formula returns with market returns over period of fewer than 5 years, there would be many instances where magic formula will fail to show its magic. However, the moment you extend your horizon to more than 5 years, the magic formula starts shining. In fact, the short term poorer performance of magic formula is what creates the foundation for its eventual superior performance.

If the magic formula worked all the time, everyone would probably use it. If everyone used it, it would probably stop working. So many people would be buying the shares of the bargain-priced stocks selected by the magic formula that the prices of those shares would be pushed higher almost immediately…That’s why we’re so lucky the magic formula isn’t that great. It doesn’t work all the time. In fact, it might work for years. Most people just won’t wait that long. Their investment time horizon is too short. If a strategy works in the long run (meaning it sometimes takes three, four, or even five years to show its stuff), most people won’t stick with it.

In other words, the main (and invisible) ingredient of the magic formula is patience. The formula can only spin its magic if the investor is willing to follow the recipe without letting the moods of Mr. Market affect the decision-making process.

Conclusion

Investing cannot be boiled down to a simple formula. If it was that easy, you won’t see so many people losing their shirt in the stock market. Having said that, the magic formula is very useful for two reasons. First, it’s a great starting point to generate a list of ideas that can be researched further. Second, for those who don’t have time and inclination to study the individual stocks i.e. the part time investors, and still want to beat the index funds, the thought process behind magic formula will help you devise your own method of investing your money safely in stock market.

In the end, the philosophy behind the formula is to ignore the emotions and diligently follow a predefined process. Even if you don’t implement the magic formula, there’s one lesson that you should take from this book – long term success in investing requires extreme patience and a strict discipline to remove factors, like excess emotion and future projections, that often lead to bad investment results.

This little book packs a punch and what’s even more interesting is Greenblatt’s entertaining style of explaining investing concepts in simple language.

[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]

Want to Read More? This content is exclusive for members of Value Investing Almanack. Login to read if you are a member. Else, click here to subscribe.

Benefits to VIA Members
 
  • Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
  • InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
  • StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
  • Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
  • BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
  • Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
  • Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
Become a VIA Member. Click to Subscribe
[/hide_from]

Filed Under: Special Report

Handcrafted with in India