Antifragile, written by Nassim Nicholas Taleb, contains more than four hundred pages (excluding the appendix) of densely packed insights and concentrated doses of ideas. And it would be very hard for me, and unfair to you, if I try to squeeze in all the learning from this book in one article.
So I am going to split this BookWorm post into multiple parts. This is the first part. We will be covering the second part (and more, if required) in subsequent VIA issues.
Nassim Taleb is one of my favourite authors. Before Antifragile he had authored two other best-selling books – The Black Swan and Fooled by Randomness, both of which are also must-reads. In fact, all three books are quite related to each other, like a trilogy. Many of the ideas that Taleb wrote about in his earlier two books, have found their logical conclusion in Antifragile.
<!–more–>[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
In The Black Swan, Taleb showed that highly improbable and unpredictable events underlie almost everything about our world. In Antifragile he stands uncertainty on its head, making it desirable, even necessary. Antifragile takes the central idea of The Black Swan and expands it to encompass almost every other aspect of life, from the 19th century rise of the nation state to what to eat for breakfast.
Let’s first understand the concept of antifragility. We know what fragile is – something which breaks or disintegrates easily when subjected to a stress or disorder. So what can be the opposite of fragile? ‘Robust’ or ‘resilient’? These are the words that came to my mind when I tried to answer this for the first time.
Think about it, is ‘staying same’ the opposite of the word ‘decrease’? Because that’s what robust or resilient means – something which doesn’t break, i.e., stays the same, under stress. Opposite of fragile should ideally be something which doesn’t just resist stress but benefits from stress; gets better and better. So Taleb coins a new word – antifragile – something which is not just immune to adverse events but thrives on them.
The simplest example of an antifragile system would be a human body or for that matter our bone structure. Our bones grow stronger when subjected to moderate stress. Not only that, in absence of stress bones actually become weak and wither away. So an antifragile body doesn’t just thrive on stress but it needs it to flourish. Wind extinguishes a candle and energizes fire, Taleb says, “Likewise with randomness, uncertainty, chaos: you want to use them, not hide from them. You want to be the fire and wish for the wind.”
Taleb talks about a Triad, something similar to the skill-luck continuum which we saw in Michael Mauboussin’s book The Success Equation, in which ‘robustness’ falls in the middle. At the far left is ‘fragility’ and at the far right is ‘antifragility’.
Hydra, in Greek mythology, is a serpent-like creature and has numerous heads. Each time one is cut off, two grow back. So harm is what it likes. Hydra represents antifragility. In Hindu mythology, there is a similar character called Raktabija. A demon (asura) who has the magic boon that every drop of blood shed from his body gives rise to another Raktabija (literally the blood borne).
It’s worth noting that things are antifragile up to a certain level of stress. Even our so called antifragile body benefits from some amount of mishandling, but up to a point – it would not benefit too much from being thrown down from the Eiffel Tower.
Antifragility in Nature
When you exercise or lift heavy weights, it exerts stress on your body. As a result, muscle fibres break down but how does the body respond to this strain? The body’s response is to overcompensate to the trauma and come out stronger than before. This process of overreaction to stress and harm is how mother nature operates. It is the process of life itself. The reverse holds true as well: Remove stress from a system, and that system grows weak. Stay in bed for three weeks instead of lifting weights, and muscles atrophy.
Forest fires are another great example of how nature removes the fragility. The analogy between forest fire and economy here is quite interesting –
Small forest fires periodically cleanse the system of the most flammable material, so this does not have the opportunity to accumulate. Systematically preventing forest fires from taking place “to be safe” makes the big one much worse. For similar reasons, stability is not good for the economy: firms become very weak during long periods of steady prosperity devoid of setbacks, and hidden vulnerabilities accumulate silently under the surface – so delaying crisis is not a very good idea. Likewise, absence of fluctuations in the market causes hidden risks to accumulate with impunity. The longer one goes without a trauma, the worse the damage when commotion occurs.
Debt Makes You Fragile
Debt not only takes away the safety, it actually makes your finances extremely fragile in the face of unexpected adversity. It is the opposite of redundancy. . Taleb quips –
When you don’t have debt you don’t care about your reputation in economic circles – and somehow it is only when you don’t care about your reputation that you tend to have a good one.
Isn’t this obvious that the first recommendation of any sensible personal finance advisor should be to get rid of personal debt and create an emergency fund. This will make sure that you don’t get wiped out in the face emergency and have sufficient cushion to build your financial strength again. Now while are on the topic of fragility, it’s appropriate to introduce the term Fragilista, coined by the author, which in short refers to the one who makes you engage in policies and actions, all man-made, in which the benefits are small and visible, and the side-effects potentially severe and invisible.
Non-Predictive Decision Making
The mental model of antifragility is very useful in dealing with uncertainty in various human affairs including business, politics, medicine and life in general. A system of non-predictive decision making is required in any situation where there is randomness, unpredictability or incomplete understanding of things. And how do you deal with this uncertainty? You don’t need to forecast the rare, high impact events (Black Swans). You only need to figure out if your systems are fragile. Taleb suggests –
..we can almost always detect antifragility (and fragility) using a simple test of asymmetry: anything that has more upside than downside from random events (or certain shocks) is antifragile; the reverse is fragile.
In a discussion of the earthquake and tsunami that produced the 2011 Fukushima nuclear disaster in Japan, Taleb writes –
Not seeing a tsunami or an economic event coming is excusable; building something fragile to them is not…It had been built to withstand the worst past historical earthquake, with the builders not imagining much worse – and not thinking that the worst past event had to be a surprise, as it had no precedent.
…In the wake of Fukushima disaster, instead of predicting failure and the probabilities of disaster, these intelligent nuclear firms are now aware that they should instead focus on exposure to failure – making the prediction or nonprediction of failure quite irrelevant. This approach leads to building small enough reactors and embedding them deep enough in the ground with enough layers of protection around them that a failure would not affect us much should it happen – costly, but still better than nothing.
Antifragility of the Aggregate
Mind you, when we talk about antifragility in human affairs, the antifragility of a system as whole is more important and relevant than an individual. We can mistake the antifragility of the system for that of the individual, when in fact it takes place at the expense of the individual. I’ll let Taleb explain it –
For the economy to be antifragile and undergo what is called evolution, every single individual business must necessarily be fragile, exposed to breaking – evolution needs organisms (or their genes) to die when supplanted by others, in order to achieve improvement, or to avoid reproduction when they are not as fit as someone else. Accordingly, the antifragility of the higher level may require the fragility – and sacrifice – of the lower one. Every time you use a coffeemaker for your morning cappuccino, you are benefiting from the fragility of the coffee-making entrepreneur who failed. He failed in order to help put the superior merchandise on your kitchen counter.
So it’s easy to see how the aviation industry benefits from a plane crash. Every small error lowers the odds of future mistakes and makes the air travel much safer for future. Whereas in a badly designed system (like banking) where the individual entities are networked and hopelessly entangled with each other, an error (bank crash) in this complex system increases the odds of chain reaction.
Antifragility in Business
Here is a very insightful excerpt from the book –
Some businesses love their own mistakes. Reinsurance companies who focus on insuring catastrophic risks (and are used by insurance companies to “re-insure” such non-diversifiable risks), manage to do well after a calamity or tail event that causes them to take a hit. If they are still in business and “have their powder dry” (few manage to have plans for such contingency), they make it up by disproportionately raising premia – customers overreact and pay up for insurance. They claim to have no idea about fair value, that is, proper pricing, for reinsurance, but they certainly know that it is overpriced at times of stress, which is sufficient to them to make a long term shekel. All they need is to keep their mistakes small enough so they can survive them.
Warren Buffett probably understood this and that’s why he refused to participate in the race for mindless growth for his insurance subsidiaries. A relentless focus on underwriting profitability made sure that he had his “powder dry” when other fragile competitors would routinely get wiped out in the event of one bad year. Buffett’s Berkshire, in my opinion, is the epitome of an antifragile business.
Caveat Emptor
I would like to be honest with you here. I don’t agree with everything that Taleb proposes in his book. In fact my copy is heavily marked with my own comments refuting author’s conclusions at many places. In spite of that or perhaps because of that, I found this book immensely insightful and I loved reading it. For a book like Antifragile, it’s just not possible, at least not for me, to summarise the ideas in few pages. It’s a thought provoking book which needs to be read and re-read. In fact every time I open a chapter, I do that from time to time to get that kick, I find new connections and insights.
I’ll present some more stuff from this book in the next issue of Bookworm, but I suggest don’t wait until then. Get a copy for yourself and read it.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years