If I ask you, “Are you unhappy?” what kind of thoughts have I triggered in your mind?
For most people presented with this question, the mind invariably wanders off to some of the unpleasant episodes in life. There’s nothing to worry if this was a question asked in a happiness survey by an innocent volunteer. But such questions are typically framed by people who are in the business of persuasion or manipulation. This is a trick question which is designed to lead your mind precisely to those thoughts which the questioner wants you to think.
Robert Cialdini, in his new book Pre-Suasion, has termed this persuasion strategy as Target Chuting. He writes –
If I inquired whether you were unhappy in, let’s say, the social arena, your natural tendency to hunt for confirmations rather than for disconfirmations of the possibility would lead you to find more proof of discontent than if I asked whether you were happy there. This was the outcome when members of a sample of Canadians were asked either if they were unhappy or happy with their social lives. Those asked if they were unhappy were far more likely to encounter dissatisfactions as they thought about it and, consequently, were 375 percent more likely to declare themselves unhappy.
And the reason for such tendency is our good old confirmation bias. Its scientific name is positive test strategy, writes Cialdini, “But it comes down to this: in deciding whether a possibility is correct, people typically look for hits rather than misses; for confirmations of the idea rather than for disconfirmations. It is easier to register the presence of something than its absence.”
And once your attention has been drawn towards a specific set of thoughts, the mind tends to assign unnecessarily high weightage to those thoughts.
<!–more–>[show_to accesslevel=’almanack-all’]
Daniel Kahneman writes, “Nothing in life is as important as you think it is, while you are thinking about it.” Why? Because you’re thinking about it!
Kahneman has named this mental quirk as focusing illusion. It’s a behavioural bias which has deep implications in the way humans make decisions and experience life.
Your mind makes a huge deal out of anything which it’s thinking about. Whether it’s a good thought or a bad thought.
Here’s a very thoughtful example from Kahneman’s book Thinking, Fast and Slow –
–Compare two commitments that will change some aspects of your life: buying a comfortable new car and joining a group that meets weekly, perhaps a poker or book club. Both experiences will be novel and exciting at the start. The crucial difference is that you will eventually pay little attention to the car as you drive it, but you will always attend to the social interaction to which you committed yourself. By WYSIATI [availability and recency bias], you’re likely to exaggerate the long-term benefits of the car, but you’re not likely to make the same mistake for a social gathering or for inherently attention-demanding activities such as playing tennis or learning to play the cello. The focusing illusion creates a bias in favour of goods and experiences that are initially exciting, even if they will eventually lose their appeal. Time is neglected, causing experiences that will retain their attention value in the long term to be ppreciated less than they deserve to be.
Focusing illusion is a very powerful weapon of persuasion for sales and marketing guys. They are redirecting their customer’s focus on circumstances which build the case for the need of the product being sold.
Focusing illusion is also the reason why most people go through life with a perennial state of discontent and fear. Your five senses primarily determine the amount of enjoyment you can extract out of an experience or an object. The problem is that when we are focused on a thought, we have a tendency to blow it out of proportion. Our imagination (hope and fear) has no limits but your five senses are constrained by physical and biological limits.
Nothing in life is as pleasurable as you hoped it would be and nothing painful is as bad as you feared it would be.
Unfortunately, focusing illusion, like all other cognitive biases, is like a mirage. It’s almost impossible for humans to differentiate between a mirage and reality until it’s too late. Similarly, despite being aware of focusing illusion, you and I would continue falling for it.
Kahneman makes a remarkable observation in his book –
Paraplegics are often unhappy, but they are not unhappy all the time because they spend most of the time experiencing and thinking about other things than their disability. When we think of what it is like to be a paraplegic, or blind, or a lottery winner, or a resident of California we focus on the distinctive aspects of each of these conditions. The mismatch in the allocation of attention between thinking about a life condition and actually living it is the cause of the focusing illusion. The mismatch in the allocation of attention between thinking about a life condition and actually living it is the cause of the focusing illusion.
Focusing illusion is also a cause of undue stress which is omnipresent in our environment these days. Thinking about an upcoming job interview is unavoidable. In fact, it’s even useful because it helps you prepare for it.
But when the mind unknowingly starts giving too much importance to the outcome of the interview, the attention drifts towards unpleasant thoughts e.g., how would you feel if the outcome is undesired. And that thought makes the present moment intolerable, even if you’re sitting in your new car.
So we see that focusing illusion wreaks havoc in multiple ways. Stress, discontent, unreasonable expectations are all different cut of the same meat i.e., focusing illusion.
Newspapers and TV news channels exacerbate this effect. They are experts in creating breaking news out of ordinary events. When an obscure 2-seater plane crashes in the woods, they showcase that story (24X7 until they find another sensational story) as if air travel has suddenly turned life threatening for everyone on the planet.
When the stock market corrects by 10 percent, they start shouting how the economy is about to come down on its knees. The recency and artificial vividness of these events create a very lopsided view of the world in our eyes.
This bias severely affects an individual’s decision-making capabilities too. It distracts us from the real thing. In trying to answer the question – On an average, are rich people happier than poor people? – most people unknowingly answer a different question i.e., “Is income an important factor in determining individual’s happiness levels?”
That’s another bias called substitution principle. When a satisfactory answer to a question is not found quickly, our mind tends to imagine a related question that is easier and construct an answer for it. We had written about it in the December 2016 issue of Value Investing Almanack.
When you think of rich and poor people, writes Kahneman, “your thoughts are inevitably focused on circumstances in which their income is important.”
So how does focusing illusion brings trouble in investing?
When one is doing the valuation of a company, because of focusing illusion, it’s natural to get hung up on the numbers and give undue weightage to how cheap or expensive the company is. The folly is that we’re exaggerating the importance of one variable (in this case, valuation) merely by thinking about it lots.
Similarly, when you’re reading to assess the quality of the company, the thought of valuation may get ignored completely.
Using the checklist is a great way to remedy this illusion. Once you have read up about the company and done your calculations, a checklist helps to defocus you from one single factor. It draws your attention to various other factors that you might have overlooked.
Everything that counts cannot be counted, goes the adage, and everything that can be counted doesn’t necessarily count. Focusing illusion makes us count those things which don’t count as much.
Let me close this with a more useful question, “Are you happy?” I hope this question pulls your mind’s attention to the good things in your life and feel grateful for them.
[/show_to] [hide_from accesslevel=’almanack-all’]- Spotlight: Big ideas from Value Investing and why applying them in your investment decision making will be a great deal
- InvestorInsights: Interviews with experienced value investors, learners, and deep thinkers
- StockTalk: Thorough analysis of business models of companies (without any recommendations)
- Behaviouronomics: Deep analysis of human behaviour and how it impacts investment decision making
- BookWorm: Reviews of the best books on Value Investing and related subjects
- Free Course – Financial Statement Analysis for Smart People (otherwise priced at Rs 5,900)
- Archives: Instant access to our huge archive from the past three years
